Atlas, a former chief of neuroradiology at Stanford who now focuses on healthcare policy, suggested the virus should be allowed to spread through the population so that people build up immunity, rather than trying to contain it through shutdown measures, according to the Washington Post.
At a town hall event a few weeks later, President Trump raised the idea himself, saying the coronavirus would simply “go away,†as people developed “herd mentality†— a slip-up that was understood to be a reference to the same concept.
Rand Paul (R-Ky.) sparked a heated debate at a committee hearing when he suggested that the decline in COVID-19 cases in New York City was due to herd or community immunity rather than public health measures, such as wearing masks and social distancing.
infectious disease official, rebuked Paul, pointing out that only 22% of the city’s residents have coronavirus antibodies.
Get our free Coronavirus Today newsletter.
“If you believe 22% is herd immunity, I believe you’re alone in that,†Fauci told the senator.
Paul isn’t the only one who’s confused about herd immunity.
Herd immunity, also called community or population immunity, refers to the point at which enough people are sufficiently resistant to a disease that an infectious agent is unlikely to spread from person to person.
As a result, the whole community — including those who don’t have immunity — becomes protected.
People generally gain immunity in one of two ways: vaccination or infection.
Vaccines have been the route to herd immunity for most diseases in recent history, including smallpox, polio, diphtheria and rubella.
Before the COVID-19 pandemic, experts can’t recall an example in which governments intentionally turned to natural infection to achieve herd immunity.
Generally, such a strategy could lead to widespread illness and death, said Dr.
“It’s a terrible idea,†Del Rio said?
still has a long way to go to achieve herd immunity to the coronavirus that causes COVID-19.
A large study published last week in the medical journal Lancet found that fewer than 1 in 10 Americans have antibodies to SARS-CoV-2, the formal name for the coronavirus.
Even in the hardest-hit areas, like New York City, estimates of immunity among residents are about 25%.
Could a ‘controlled avalanche’ stop the coronavirus faster, and with fewer deaths.
Could a ‘controlled avalanche’ stop the coronavirus faster, and with fewer deaths.
Israeli scientists say they can mimic the effects of a vaccination campaign if certain people willingly get infected with the coronavirus and recover.
To reach 50% to 70% immunity would mean about four times as many people getting infected and an “incredible number of deaths,†said Josh Michaud, associate director of global health policy at the Henry J.
“It’s not a strategy to pursue unless your goal is to pursue suffering and death,†Michaud said.
Some scientists say natural immunity may not be a feasible defense against COVID-19.
Although most people presumably achieve some degree of protection against the coronavirus after being infected once, cases of people who recovered from COVID-19 and were reinfected have raised questions about how long natural immunity lasts and whether someone with immunity could still spread the virus.
As the economy reopens, scientists still have a lot to learn about coronavirus immunity.
As the economy reopens, scientists still have a lot to learn about coronavirus immunity.
In exploring coronavirus immunity as the nation reopens, scientists still want to know how long immunity lasts and whether it protects everyone equally.
Even the method scientists are using to measure immunity — blood tests that detect antibodies to the coronavirus — may not be an accurate indicator of who is protected against COVID-19, said Dr.
With so many unanswered questions, “we can’t count on natural herd immunity as a way to control this epidemic,†he said.
Vaccines, on the other hand, can be made to trigger stronger immunity than natural infection, Ray said.
The hope is that vaccines being developed for COVID-19 will provide the same higher level of immunity.
In the political debate around COVID-19, proponents of a natural herd immunity strategy often point to Sweden as a model.
Although the Scandinavian country imposed fewer economic shutdown measures, its death rate is less than that of the U.S., Paul said at Wednesday’s Senate hearing.
Sweden has escaped a second coronavirus wave so far.
Sweden has escaped a second coronavirus wave so far.
Sweden’s relatively low-key approach to coronavirus lockdowns captured the world’s attention, but the strategy’s effectiveness remains unclear.
But health experts — including Fauci during the same hearing — said that’s a flawed comparison.
has a much more diverse population, with vulnerable groups like Black and Latino Americans being disproportionately affected by the coronavirus, said Dr.
also has greater population density, especially on the coasts, he said.
When compared with other Scandinavian countries, Sweden’s death toll is much higher.
It has had 5,880 deaths linked to COVID-19 so far, according to data from Johns Hopkins University.
That’s nearly 58 deaths per 100,000 residents — several times higher than the death rates of 5 or 6 per 100,000 in Norway and Finland.
In fact, as a result of COVID-19, Sweden has recorded its highest death toll since a famine swept the country 150 years ago.
Despite that level of loss, it’s still unclear if Sweden has reached the threshold for herd immunity.
A study by the country’s public health agency found that by late April only 7% of residents in Stockholm had antibodies for COVID-19.
COVID-19 death toll hits 1 million amid fears of renewed outbreaks.
COVID-19 death toll hits 1 million amid fears of renewed outbreaks.
The global COVID-19 death toll surpassed 1 million, one measurement of a scourge that has ravaged lives and economies and evoked an era of plagues.
— with the exception of New York City — less than 10% of the population had coronavirus antibodies by June, according to a study in JAMA Internal Medicine5
The results led commentators in the Lancet to write, “In light of these findings, any proposed approach to achieve herd immunity through natural infection is not only highly unethical, but also unachievable.â€.
Natural herd immunity is an uncertain strategy, and attempts to pursue it could result in a slew of unnecessary deaths, medical experts say.
“As we wait for new tools to be added to the toolbox,†Andrus said, “we have to keep reminding ourselves that there are measures in this very moment that we could be using to save lives.â€
Get our free Coronavirus Today newsletter
in the last 6½ months,, at least 277,285 schoolchildren in 38 states tested positive for the coronavirus, the CDC reported
Feds to ship millions of coronavirus rapid tests in bid to reopen K-12 schools
Feds to ship millions of coronavirus rapid tests in bid to reopen K-12 schools
President Trump has announced the shipment of millions of rapid coronavirus tests to states this week
What we’ve learned from the nearly 1 million who’ve died of COVID-19
What we’ve learned from the nearly 1 million who’ve died of COVID-19
The nearly 1 million people who have lost their lives to COVID-19 also have given the world a gift: a better understanding of how to treat the disease
Social media takes COVID-19 shaming to new levels
Social media takes COVID-19 shaming to new levels
But the practice has taken on new aggression in the COVID-19 era
So much for shaking hands and kissing babies: How COVID-19 is reshaping L.A
So much for shaking hands and kissing babies: How COVID-19 is reshaping L.A
Many of the familiar rituals of stumping for votes are off the table during the COVID-19 pandemic, drastically changing what it looks like to run for office in L.A
The Southern California median home price rose 12% in August, as people took advantage of rock-bottom interest rates amid the COVID-19 outbreak
Sweden has escaped a second coronavirus wave so far
Sweden has escaped a second coronavirus wave so far
UK
Australia
France
Germany
Russia
India
Canada